|
Noel Malcolm reviews The
Whisperers: Private Life In Stalin's Russia by Orlando Figes.
Here are three stories of ordinary Soviet life
in the 1930s.
Aleksandr and Serafima Ozemblovsky,
impoverished ex-nobles who farmed with their former peasants in a village in
Belarus, were arrested in 1930 and sent into exile 2,000 miles away in the
sub-Arctic north. Their crime was being 'kulaks', a term used of any farmers
who were hard-working and successful. As people in their penal settlement began to die
of hunger, Serafima took her two small daughters and set off back to Belarus,
hiding by day and walking at night. When they reached her parents' house, the
parents were so terrified that they begged her to give herself up to the
police.
She left her daughters and returned to the
penal settlement, where she found that her husband had been arrested and taken
to a labour camp; she too was arrested, but escaped and rejoined her daughters
– after another trek of 2,000 miles.
Ilia and Aleksandra Faivisovich were
hairdressers in a small town in the Urals. In 1939 customers reported them to
the police for complaining about shortages; they were accused of 'anti-Soviet
conspiracy', and sent to labour camps.
Their four-year-old daughter ended up with her
maternal grandmother, who told her never to talk about her parents. Every week
a letter arrived from the imprisoned Aleksandra to her daughter, and every week
the grandmother burnt it without opening it.
A woman called Liza (her family name is
unknown), incarcerated on trumped-up charges in 1937, received letters from her
beloved daughter, Zoia. One day the letter said: 'Dear Mama, I'm 15 years old
now and I'm planning to join the Komsomol [the Communist youth movement:
membership was essential for a high-flying career]. I have to know whether you
are guilty or not. I keep thinking, how could you have betrayed our Soviet
power?'
When she received this, Liza was already on
the last page of a letter she was writing to Zoia. She took her pen and wrote:
'Zoia, you are right. I am guilty. Join the Komsomol. This is the last time I
am going to write to you. Be happy. Mother.' Then, according to the
fellow-prisoner who witnessed this, she gave way to uncontrollable tears and
banged her head on the table.
Stories such as these have been told many
times in the past; for anyone who wants to learn about human suffering under
Stalin, there are classic individual memoirs (Nadezhda Mandelshtam) and
authoritative analyses (Robert Conquest on the Great Terror; Anne Applebaum on
the Gulags).
But Orlando Figes's new book is not a general
history of the Terror. It is both broader than that, covering the whole period
between 1917 and the 1950s, and more narrowly focused. Its subject is the
nature of ordinary life – above all, the nature of the family under Communist
rule.
The early Bolsheviks were not just political
revolutionaries: they believed that every aspect of human life would be
transformed under Communism, and the traditional family was one of the things
that had to go. 'By loving a child, the family turns him into an egotist',
complained one Bolshevik theorist; the ABC of Communism (1919) looked forward
to a time when parents would no longer use the word 'my' to refer to their
children.
To achieve these goals, people were crammed
into communal apartments; new blocks were specially designed to enforce
communal living, and an old four-bedroom flat might have six families living in
it, sharing one kitchen. (There are some fascinating floor-plan diagrams in
this book.)
Devoted Communists cared little about creature
comforts, and often cared almost as little about their families; the only focus
of loyalty was the Party. And a generation of children, in turn, was brought up
to idealise the famous Communist boy-martyr, Pavlik Morozov, who denounced his own
father to the authorities and was allegedly murdered for doing so.
In the early 1930s, however, the official
policy changed, partly because of a worrying fall in the birth-rate, and partly
because a new urban middle class was emerging (engineers, technicians, and so
on), for which family life still held its old attractions. And in some ways the
inefficiency of the Soviet state made family bonds more important: there was so
much that could be achieved only through personal favours by friends and
relations.
But what proved the fundamental strength of
the family, while testing it almost to destruction, was state terror – not just
the Great Terror of the late 1930s, but wave after wave of terror against whole
sections of the population. 'Kulaks' in the 1920s and 1930s, many ethnic groups
in the Second World War, returning PoWs after 1945, and Jews in the
anti-Semitic purges of Stalin's final years: all yielded innumerable stories of
suffering similar to the three above.
Sometimes, as those stories show, fear of the
state trumped family love; sometimes the two worked in a strange kind of
synergy, with parents longing to see their children turn into unthinking (and
therefore, they hoped, happy) little specimens of homo sovieticus. Those who
wanted their children to know something of the truth, meanwhile, were reduced
to a lifetime of 'whispering'.
Orlando Figes has performed an astonishing
task. He has organised the interviewing of many hundreds of survivors of those
years, all over Russia; he has scoured provincial archives, has read a host of
published memoirs, and has studied the faded letters and diaries that people
have brought out of their hiding-places to show him.
As if that were not enough, he has also woven
into the book a larger biographical case-history, of a once-famous writer,
Konstantin Simonov, whose own tangled family life and moral compromises with
the Soviet regime make him an emblematic figure, a kind of flawed anti-hero,
redeemed by his long final years of remorse.
Figes organises his material superbly, and
writes with such self-effacing lucidity that these people seem to speak
directly to the reader. This is a very important book – authoritative, vivid,
precise, and, in places, almost unbearably moving
www.telegraph.co.uk |